Constitutional exceptions of right to speech: Evidence from the apex courts of Pakistan
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.47264/idea.jhsms/2.1.7Keywords:
constitution, unqualified right, limitations, apex court, superior court, judicial precedents, pre-conditionAbstract
Every right is subject to some correlated duty. The Constitution of Pakistan has envisaged certain limitations on the ultimate right to speech. Unqualified fundamental rights ought not to exist in a society. Freedom of speech is known as a pre-condition to all sorts of fundamental rights yet has certain limitations regarding its enjoyment. The restriction on the basic right to speech under the Constitution can be stated as the problem statement of this research. While unveiling the restrictions provided in the Constitution of Pakistan is the basic research question and the research objective is to find out the adequacy of restrictions regarding freedom of speech and draw an inference in the light of case laws. The following article’s qualitative research comprises a case law study that elaborates judicial precedents regarding limitations on freedom of speech. This research article emphasizes that the right of freedom of speech must prevail in all the circumstances, yet the citizens are also accountable and have to face the music otherwise. On the other hand, the court must remain impartial while interpreting the Constitution with the prudent mind in a broader spectrum. The theory of necessity must be buried under the deep layers of earth.
References
Alexander, L., & Horton, P. (1984). The impossibility of a free speech principle. Northwestern Law Review, 78(5), 1319ff.
Aligarh Muslim University Old Boys Cooperative Housing Society Limited versus Muhammad Yousef Qureshi, CLC 732 (Karachi High Court Sindh, 1997). https://www.amu.ac.in/non-teaching/saiyyid-hamid-senior-secondary-school-boys/mohammad-yousuf
Amir Hamza, Ex S.S.P versus Federation of Pakistan, PLC 732 (C S, 1997).
Abdullah Malik versus Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, PLD 2017 (Lahore 273).
Asma Jilani versus the government of the Punjab and another, PLD 39 (Supreme Court, 1972). http://andyreiter.com/wp-content/uploads/militaryjustice/pk/Court%20Cases/Pakistan%20-%201972%20-%20Asma%20Jilani%20v.%20Government%20of%20Punjab.pdf
Barendt, E. (1994). Free speech in Australia: a comparative perspective. Sydney L. Rev., 16, 149.
Baz Muhammad Kakar versus Federation of Pakistan, PLD 870 (Supreme Court, 2012). https://cite.pakcaselaw.com/pld-supreme-court/2012/870/
Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) reprints. (n.d.). https://www.lawlibrary.vic.gov.au/crimes-act-1958-vic-reprints
D.G. Khan Cement Ltd versus Federation of Pakistan, PLD 693 (Lahore High Court, 2013). https://cite.pakcaselaw.com/PLD-LAHORE-HIGH-COURT-LAHORE/2013/693/
Engr. Jameel Ahmed Malik versus Pakistan Ordinance Factories Board, Wah Cantt, SCMR 1640 (Supreme Court, 2004). https://cite.pakcaselaw.com/scmr-supreme-court/2004/164/
Fish, S. (1994). There's no such thing as free speech…and it's a good thing too. Oxford University.
Feinberg, J. (1988). Offence to others. Oxford University (Volume 2 of the moral limits of the criminal law).
High Court Bar Association versus Government of Baluchistan, PLD 75 (Baluchistan, 2013). https://bhc.gov.pk/resources/judgments/justice-qazi-faez-isa/reported-judgments#lg=gl_judgements&slide=0
Haworth, A. (1998). Free speech. Routledge
Hussain Bakhsh Kausar versus the State, PLD 15 (Peshawar, 1958). https://peshawarhighcourt.gov.pk/PHCCMS/reportedJudgments.php?action=search
Imran Khan, Chairman of Pakistan Tehrek.i.Insaf, PLD 367 (Supreme Court, 2014). https://cite.pakcaselaw.com/PLD-SUPREME-COURT/2014/367/
Jefferson, M. (2007). Criminal law. Pearson Education.
K.A Muhammad Khan versus the State, AIR 104 (Kerala 1964). https://indiankanoon.org/doc/603304/
Mahmood, S., & Shaukat, N. (2008). The Pakistan Penal Code (section 40). Lahore: Legal Research Centre.
Masroor Ahsan versus Ardeshir Cowasji, PLD 823 (Supreme Court, 1998).
Miss Sadia Sumble Butt versus Rafiq Afghan, MLD 1462 (Karachi High Court, 2006). https://cite.pakcaselaw.com/MLD-KARACHI-HIGH-COURT-SINDH/2006/1462/
Muhammad Din versus The State, 1995 PLD 469 (Karachi High Court, 1995). https://cite.pakcaselaw.com/PLD-KARACHI-HIGH-COURT-SINDH/1995/469/
Muhammad Nawaz Sharif versus President of Pakistan and others, PLD 473 (Supreme Court, 1993). http://nasirlawsite.com/historic/pld473.htm
Muhammad Safdar versus West Pakistan, PLD 236 (Peshawar, 1965).
Mill, J. S. (1978). On Liberty. Hackett Publishing.
Mill, J.S. (1859) On liberty. Harvard Classics edition, 1909. http://www.serendipity.li/jsmill/on_lib.html
Nawab Zada Nasrullah Khan versus Government of West Pakistan, PLD 642 (Lahore, 1965). https://cite.pakcaselaw.com/PLD-LAHORE-HIGH-COURT-LAHORE/1965/642/
Nawabzada Nasrullah Khan versus The District Magistrate, Lahore & The Government of West Pakistan PLD 642 (W.P) (Lahore, 1965). https://cite.pakcaselaw.com/PLD-LAHORE-HIGH-COURT-LAHORE/1965/642/
Pakistan Chest Foundation versus Government of Pakistan, CLC 1379 (1997). https://cite.pakcaselaw.com/CLC-LAHORE-HIGH-COURT-LAHORE/1997/1379/
Pakistan Muslim League (N) through Khawaja Muhammad Asif, M.N.A. versus Federation of Pakistan, PLD 642 (Supreme Court, 2007). https://cite.pakcaselaw.com/pld-supreme-court/2007/642/
Pakistan Broadcaster Association versus Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority, PLD 2016 (Supreme Court 692)
PLD 661 (Lahore 1964). https://cite.pakcaselaw.com/PLD-LAHORE-HIGH-COURT-LAHORE/1964/661/
Rases Ghulam Sarwar versus Mansoor Sadiq Zaidi, PLD 458 (Karachi 2008). https://cite.pakcaselaw.com/PLD-KARACHI-HIGH-COURT-SINDH/2008/458/
Sheikh Muhammad Rashid versus Majid Nizami, PLD 514 (Supreme Court, 2002). https://cite.pakcaselaw.com/pld-supreme-court/2002/514/
State versus Pakistan Medical and Dental Council of Islamabad, PLD 12 (Lahore, 1989). https://sys.lhc.gov.pk/appjudgments/2017LHC3892.pdf
Sutlej Cotton Mills Ltd. versus Industrial Court, PLD 472 (Supreme Court, 1966). https://cite.pakcaselaw.com/PLD-SUPREME-COURT/1966/472/
Suo Moto case no 28 of 2018, PLD 2019 (Supreme Court 1)
Suo Moto case no 7 of 2017, PLD 2019 (Supreme Court 318)
Taffazal Hossain versus Government of East Pakistan, PLD 589 (Dacca, 1969). https://cite.pakcaselaw.com/PLD-DHAKA-HIGH-COURT/1969/589/
Taffazal Hussain versus Government of East Pakistan, PLD 68 (Dacca, 1965). http://cite.pakcaselaw.com/PCRLJ-DHAKA-HIGH-COURT/1968/734/
Taj Din and others Versus The State, PLD 490 (SC 1975).
The Security of Pakistan Act, 1952 (Act No. XXXV of 1952). http://nasirlawsite.com/laws/sop.htm
The State versus Abdul Ghaffar Khan (Bacha Khan), PLD 142 (Lahore, 1957).
The State versus Sheikh Shukat Ali Advocate, PLD 355 (Lahore, 1976). https://cite.pakcaselaw.com/pld-lahore-high-court-lahore/1976/714/
The State versus Taj Din and others, PLD 434 (Lahore, 1972).
Van-Mill, D. (2021). Freedom of speech. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Spring 2021 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (Ed.), https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2021/entries/freedom-speech/
Young versus Cassells, 33 N.Z.L.R. 852, 16 G.L.R. 391 (1914). 1993 SCMR 2189. http://www.lawreports.nz/young-v-cassells-1914-33-nzlr-852/
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2021 Kashif Javed, Li Jianxin, Asif Khan

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Please click here for details about the Licensing and Copyright policies of IDEA-PG.